So I’m no longer writing for Islamonline.net. I was fired
hehe. They like to call it “Administrative Changes” I wasn’t very comfortable referring people to that site anyway because of the questionable material and fatawee they had. Why exactly am I not writing for them anymore? read on…
Here was my first (and last) article I wrote for them:
Seeking the Highest
And just to give you some examples of the problems I saw:
1. When I turned in my first article they took out about 4 or 5 hadith that I used to support what I was saying. They said that Youth don’t like a lot of Quran and Hadith because it’s “Preachy.” To be honest, that’s really sad. The people who go to read Islamic articles online, aren’t really the ones who are completely lost. Also it supported what I said, and gave my words more credibility. So that was strike number one.
2. The way they edited my article: I was not made aware of the changes they had made to my article until after it was published. There were a couple of things, but the thing that surprised me the most was this sentence: “If you work toward haram goals in this world, your ultimate goal is lost; the goal of attaining Al-Firdaws; seeking Allah’s grace.”
They had changed “Seeking Allah’s FACE to grace” hmm no, I specifically meant Face. (Jallah wa 3ala.) Which tells me there’s a little bit of denying Allah’s names and attributes going on there. Although there is nothing wrong with seeking Allah’s grace, I’d rather not have people edit my articles as such.
3. They tried to control all email content! (which is actually the reason I believe they let me go):
If you look under the articles they have a generic email address. I asked them how I can check the email that gets sent to me or where it gets forwarded to, and they told me that it’s policy that they don’t let their writers have access to the emails. Instead, they will forward the emails to the writer if it is addressed to them. They also mentioned that they like to “See the feedback, and see how their writers are doing.”
That was strange to me. I’ve never seen any newspaper or magazine or company in general monitor the emails.
If that wasn’t enough:
4. They made me CC them when I would reply to the emails that would be sent to me. It was like Big Brother. Why do they need to see the naseeha that I’m giving to the youth? They come to me for advice and I give it to them.
I kept questioning their policies. And apparently they didn’t like that
Anyway with that said: Me, my sister, and a friend of mine were planning on starting a blog for the youth. Just in Baton Rouge alone, we have around 30 girls that regularly come to the Youth Halaqa every Friday night at the masjid. However, I’d like to make this blog something for all youth. It’ll be awesome, inshaAllah.
More updates on that soon inshaAllah.
Stumble it!



April 13th, 2008 at 5:21 pm
I liked the purple setup…
This looks BORING!
April 23rd, 2008 at 7:16 am
Assalaamualaikum wa rahmathullaahi wa barkathuhu,
First of I would like to congratulate you folks on coming out with an amazing blog for the Muslim youth. I read your article “Seeking the Highest - This Is My Goal” on islamonline.net and also the reason why you got removed from the site.
I am impressed by the mentality that you have as not many Muslims of today have a healthy mentality(a person who thinks for himself/herself and does not take everything as it comes without questioning the ‘authority’).
I am also working on a particular format by which we can write down and keep track of our goals (in the perspective of the Qur’aan & the Sunnah).
I am trying to create a practical and easy method that can be adopted easily by anyone and that is robust in real life.
I’d be extremely glad to have some help from you or some other Muslim with like mentality as i do not usually come across like minded people often…
April 23rd, 2008 at 11:16 pm
Jazak Allah khair Br. Abdullah. Can you explain a little more about your project And what aspects you would need help with? May Allah ‘az wa jal but barakah in the work you do for His Sake, ameen.
April 24th, 2008 at 7:25 pm
Hmmm…I thought that was a reliable website on Islam…
April 24th, 2008 at 9:59 pm
Alhamdulillah, like Brotha Abdullah, I like it there are thinking Muslims out there.
May 1st, 2008 at 8:46 pm
DeenScope is coming soon inshaAllah.. this is a major project that’s going to take online Islamic Magazines to a new level inshaAllah.
If you’d like to be a writer for the magazine, please email me at shirien(at)egyptiangumbo.com