The Best Persuader: Muhammad (SAWS): Ethos

“Who are YOU to tell ME anything?!”– We’ve all heard this some point or another when we got into a “heated debate” with someone. In essence, if someone spits this out at you they most likely want your resumé; your credibility. (And most likely they think they’re better than you, bad friend I tell ya.)

I started the first post of a series on the Leechon Blog called “The Best Persuader, Muhammed (Salallahu alayhi wa sallam).” I’m currently writing a book (which has been on hold for a while) about the art(sunnah) of persuasion in light of the sunnah.

This is REALLY useful information… so read on inshaAllah:

01-kaba_duaa.jpg

(photo courtesy of futoor.com)

Yesterday, I held a conference call with my PR team and the issue of ethos, pathos and logos came up into the conversation. With these three things properly executed in a message, one can achieve persuasion, by the Will of Allah.”OK Gumbo, what are you talking about?” I’m talking about establishing credibility (ethos), having an emotional appeal (pathos) and having a factual or logial appeal (logos). And there is no doubt the Prophet salallahu alayhi wa sallam would have all three of these elements in his speech. *these terms are terms of contemporary rhetorical scholars, the Prophet salallahu alayhi wa sallam set the first and prime example for mankind*

So first let’s give examples from the life of Muhammad, salallahu alayhi wa sallam, then let’s apply that to our lives today.

When studying seerah, you will notice how scholars are not shy of establishing the credibility of the Prophet,salallahu alayhi wa sallam. For indeed, Allah ‘az wa jal chose the best of the best of the best to deliver and carry the message of Islam.

Imam Ahmad narrates a hadith in which people were talking about and describing the Prophet sal Allaahu alayhi wa sallam in different ways. For example, one person said that Muhammad sal Allaahu alayhi wa sallam was like a green tree growing in the desert. In reality what they were trying convey was that Muhammad sal Allaahu alayhi wa sallam was the only goodflower_in_desert.jpg
person in the clan. So Ibn Abbas says “certain things the people were saying reached the messenger of Allah, so he mounted the pulpit and asked, ‘Who am I?’ they replied ‘You are the messenger of Allah’ he replied ‘I am Muhammad bin Abdillah bin Abdul Muttalib. Allah divides the creation and made me amongst the best of His creatures and He made them all into two groups placing me in the better of them. He created the tribes and placed me in the better of them and divides them into clans and placed me in the best one and I’m the best of you in clan and in spirit.’”

So the prophet salallahu alayhi wa sallam is saying, I’m not the best person in a group of evil people. But instead he was saying that I am the best and from among the best. You’ll also notice that he referenced his linage back to Abdul Muttalib who was of course well known and highly respected in all of Hujaz.

The prophet sal Allaahu alayhi wa sallam also said, “Verily, Allah granted eminence to kinanah from amongst the descendants of Ishmael, and he granted eminence to Quraysh from among kinanah, and he granted eminence to the bani Hashim from Quraysh, and he granted me eminence from the tribe of Banu Hashim.”

Again, this establishes his credibility in a line of the best of tribes and clans. So what exactly does this credibility do? This catches the audience’s attention. It makes the speaker seem that whatever they have to say is both valuable and should be considered due to the that person’s ethos.

And what about other instances from seerah? The fact that the Prophet Salallahu alayhi wa sallam was NEVER an idol worshiper, never drank alcohol, that Allah protected him from listening to music before his prophethood. These are all things that can be categorized under ethos (or credibility of the speaker- salallahu alayhi wa sallam)

How does this apply to YOU?

Let’s say you make Islamic videos, write a speech to be delivered, have a blog or business, or even just give dawah to muslims and/or non-Muslims. You NEED to establish your credibility. And to use specific examples:

public-speaking2.jpgLet’s say you are giving dawah to a Muslim and you are trying to convince them to pray regularly and become more practicing. Perhaps you or someone you know was in the same position a while ago and you(or they) completely changed since that time. You should mention this experience to give you better ethos in their eyes- thus, better convincing them to take the same path you did to become closer to Allah.

Another example: Why do you think all those weight loss pills and diets catch on like wildfire? It’s because of all the testimonials they see and read about. REAL PEOPLE getting REAL RESULTS. I mean c’mon have you seen those infomercials?!

Or even just look at the sheiookh when they speak at conventions or in different communities. You will always see a moderator or MC first give an introduction with a background of the sheikh before he speaks to establish his credibility to his audience.

If they do it, you should too. Wallahu Ta’ala Alem.

*if you liked this post, remember to give it a “thumbs up” on StumbleUpon.


Add your comment

4 responses for this post

  1. abo al noom Says:

    nice post didnot finish it yet but inshallah i will give u my full review when im done
    salam
    abo al noom

  2. Neha Says:

    What if some people don’t like to present their credits/credibility….may be they just want to be simple and talk in benefit of the other. Make their aakhira good :)

    Peace!!

  3. shirien Says:

    hey salam Neha,

    establishing your credibility can be done in a lot of different ways not just by speaking about things you’ve done in the past. Ethos is also the manner in which you conduct yourself. if you dress trashy, most likely people wont listen to you seriously.

    however, i understand your concern of “riyaa’” Have the right intention. like I said, if you want to talk to another Muslim and convince them to learn Arabic for instance, you can give you’re own example and tell them that you guy reverted to Islam and you’ve been learning Arabic and it’s easy. “if I can do it, you can too”

    did that answer your question?

    p.s. neha, i’ll be reviewing your paper soon inshaAllah right after I take my final today bi’ithnillahi ta’ala.

  4. abo al noom Says:

    ok sorry for the late reply i wanted to point out some things first that having the credential and all the backing u can get doesnot mean that people will lisen to you or follow ur guidance because prophet mohamed himself had all the credential but most people didnot follow him same with other prophets like nowah and ibrahiim peace on them all all had great credentials but still their following was very small , even allah said in the quran ” if you obey most of the people on earth they will misguide you from the path of allah” and ” most of people no matter how carful you are will not be believers” so credibility is important but its not enough i think you should have talked about the fact that ur successs is not majored by how many people lisen to you but are you following the truth or not and are you just talking or are u truely sacrificing to follow this truth and that is what was very credible about prophet mohamed you should include in you book that all prophets had the best characteristcs but some of them like ibrahiim the father of all believes out of his whole community only 1 person believed in him beside his wife , but he still have a high status among prophets.
    so my point is you can be good with words and have all the credentials and have big following but that doesnot mean anything infront of allah if you are not doing things the right way or you maine goal is to get people to follow you instead of spreading wat you believe is true and sacrificing and geting out of ur comfort zone to truely live the life style you are cooling others to , not just to gain high status and make ur self a leader and have people look up to u because we notice this today alot some muslms go into da3wah so poeple can call them shiek or say o mashallah sister you are great but when he or she are faced with a test to show their dedication for the deen u notice the are the first ones to say ” sorry” not going to do it.
    the best credential is trying ur best to practice what you call others for
    sorry for the long post i just though this was an important point you should add to you essay or book
    salam
    abo al noom

Leave a Reply